Archive for May, 2009

100 Posts / Saturday Teacher Feature: Grandma

Saturday, May 16th, 2009

Well!  In less than half a year, I’ve successfully posted a hundred different useless bits of personal trivia.  This calls for a celebration!

Actually, I’ve been planning to do this for awhile, but I thought the 100th post would be a nice milestone with which to begin.  It’s occurred to me that although I never planned to become a teacher, I have grown up with and am surrounded by them.  Many of my friends and family members are teachers, and I learn from them all the time.  I thought it would be fun to start an ongoing feature wherein you get to hear from the other teachers in my life through a list of basic questions that help them talk about their jobs.

This was really more Rob’s idea, and he also helped me come up with the questions.  When we started making a list of all the teachers we know (we were on a long car trip) his first suggestion surprised me: it wasn’t one of his colleagues, our friends, or even my mother: “Your grandma,” he said.

Immediately I realized he was right.  My grandmother is a pretty amazing person.  She married my grandfather after a scandalously short courtship (not scandalous then, as it was wartime) and raised three children to school age before returning to work herself.  She taught for several more decades before retiring, and in 61 years of marriage to my dear grandfather (he died in February 2006) I’m pretty sure they never had one single fight, although he sure tried his best to rile her up (he used to say that sarcasm was his spiritual gift.)  That’s just how she is: peaceful, loving, and way too smart to be suckered into something she doesn’t want to do.

Ladies and gentlemen, Marilyn McNichols of Los Angeles, California:

What do you teach, and how long have you been teaching it?

Most of my teaching was at the upper elementary level, more specifically grades 5 and six, where I taught all subjects.  My favorite assignment, though, was when a couple of other teachers and I did team teaching, and I taught math.  I also taught social studies in grades seven and eight at the junior high level.

Who or what inspired you to teach?

My eldest sister, 13 years my senior, assisted in my classroom when she was a high school senior and I was in first grade.  She then went on to college.  Her first teaching assignment was in a country school where she was the only teacher for all eight grades.  Now in her nineties, she was recently feted by some of the students from that first teaching job.  This gives you some idea of how highly regarded she was.  I loved her dearly and wanted to follow in her footsteps — although it took me thirty years to do so!

What’s the toughest thing about teaching?

Balancing absolutes in discipline with compassion and understanding.  Because I started teaching after all three of my own children were in school, I had a keen sense of how events at home can affect a kid’s behavior, his/her ability to complete assignments on time, and his/her values.

When do you have the most fun while teaching?

  • The “aha!” moment when a student grasps a new concept (in math, for example)
  • When I try a new approach and the class suddenly finds the subject material exciting or relevant and they take off with it.

What one thing do you try to teach all of your students — the one thing that would enable you to say, “I was a good teacher”?

  • You never, never, NEVER use an apostrophe to form a plural (although this is true 99.99% of the time, I realize there are a couple of exceptions).
  • Math word problems are like a puzzle that can be solved.
  • I care about you as an individual.  Many years after he had been in my classroom, I had a note from one student who said, “I always felt you really cared about me.”  And perhaps 30 years after she left my classroom, I met a former student in a business situation who gushed to everyone in the office, “Mrs. McNichols was my very favorite teacher in all my school years!  We were very ’special’ in her class!”  These gratifying comments made me feel I had succeeded in building their self confidence, even if they really didn’t have much to be confident about!

Any parting thoughts?

I suppose I was one of millions of teachers who loved interacting with kids day after day, year after year, winning some, losing some, but always striving to help a kid do his level best and, just maybe, learn something in the effort.

(You did, Grandma.  You’ve taught so much to your children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren, and of course to all of your student’s, too.)

Pearls before Swine

Friday, May 15th, 2009

For my first few years of teaching, I treated it like a job.  In, out.  There, gone.  I didn’t bake for anything; I didn’t plan anything; I didn’t even come to anything, except what was required by my contract.  I was frustrated at times, but it was just a job.

This year, circumstances have conspired to make me more involved.  The first and biggest were the two extra classes I took on this spring; they required that I stay at school every other day until the end of the day.  Staying at school meant I had to eat lunch there, so more often than not I was buying lunch in the cafeteria and eating at my (borrowed) desk while grading papers.  I saw more of the students, heard more complaints and excuses, commiserated with more teachers and felt more and more worn out as I tried to fill the shoes of my sick friend as well as my own.

I’ve also been trying to teach well, not just teach.  That means learning a new curriculum, reading and rereading books I haven’t read in ten years (or had never read in the first place.)  And designing tests, quizzes and assignments that match my friend’s standards (did I mention she is also Department Head?)  And making it interesting and relevant with fun side projects like Afghan food and comparative studies of the different Pride & Prejudice films.

The second thing was Green Week.  It was my idea, born out of a fit of conservationism / piety after the Pope’s “New 7 Deadly Sins” proclamation last year.  From the beginning, the administration resisted almost all of my ideas: an assembly would cut out too much class time, small-group discussions would be chaotic.  They advised we come up with some creative posters and announcements, which we did.  Except, since I was now at school for announcements, I realized that students don’t actually listen to them, and on my walks to and from the cafeteria I saw the futility of hanging posters in a dark hallway that is always either packed with students or unoccupied.  The contests and prizes we had set up usually went to the one or two people who had entered.  It went okay, but overall I felt it had been a lot of effort for very little payoff.  Did we affect anyone, change any minds?  I have no idea.

The school literary magazine is my third responsibility.  It has been an exercise in trust this year, because my Creative Writing class met at the same time as the AP English class I was trying to cover (yes, at the same time; no, I don’t think that’s legal.)  So the students largely produced the book on their own.  They did an amazing job, and several weeks ago it was time to go to press.  For the last two years, my mother-in-law’s printing company has given us a discount (about an 85% discount) on the books, and we’ve been able to print much of them in color.  They get better every year, as I learn little layout tricks to teach the students; the students, in turn, are inspired and emboldened by the previous year’s books.  This year, since the class was much smaller, we produced a smaller book, but I was hoping to have much of it in color.

Except I found out that a) my mother-in-law’s printing company had fallen on hard times and would have to charge us actual rates, and b) the school was unwilling to budge an inch on the budget they had set (but never told me until then.)  So for the past three days I’ve been on the phone with various printing companies, wheeling and dealing to get at least a few color pages, and meanwhile looking all over for money.  Can we have a dress down day and charge the students a dollar apiece?  No.  Can we use extra money from the English department or the school newspaper?  No.  Can we order fewer copies, since we always have so many left over?  No, in fact, you really should be ordering more copies.  (I couldn’t make this stuff up if I tried.)

Not only that, but the administration is somehow trying to blame the situation on me.  Blame me, instead of thanking me for going to such great lengths to educate my students, to fight for them, to be the very best teacher I can be.  Blame me, instead of apologizing for the fact that they can’t come up with a few hundred dollars when I’ve brought in many thousands of dollars in donated products in the last two years.  Blame me, because it must be my fault; it couldn’t possibly be their failure to communicate.

Part of me wants to drop all of this next year: the Ecology club, the literary magazine, even the occasional lunch over grading.  I have seen so many teachers “burn out” in religious schools, and I’m beginning to see why.  It’s bad enough to wear yourself out for something, but to wear yourself out and not get thanked afterwards — in fact, to get blamed and criticized afterwards — is really demoralizing.  It was easier to forget about the inadequacies and communication breakdowns when I was breezing in and breezing out every morning.

When I was struggling in architectecture school, dealing with some nasty professors, a good friend gave me some good advice: “Don’t throw your pearls before swine.”  In other words, just do your work and then get out of there.  Don’t give it your best if it doesn’t deserve your best.  Save your best for a worthy time and place.  Does that apply here?  I couldn’t tell you.

I Have Arrived

Wednesday, May 13th, 2009

A day or two ago, I was administering a test when I heard some girls making noise in the hallway, laughing and talking loudly — probably having been sent out there for similar behavior.  I stepped outside and asked them to be quiet, as my students were taking a test.  They dropped their eyes and apologized.  I returned to my classroom and continued grading papers.

That’s all.  But a little later that day, I got to thinking about the experience.  I didn’t hesitate or deliberate for a moment; it was second nature to invoke my Teacher Power for the benefit of my students.  I wasn’t mad, and I wasn’t mean, but the girls in the hall obviously felt chastised. How many times during my grade school years was I similarly called out?  I’m sure there were many that even Kirsten doesn’t remember.  I was smart and a smart-aleck — oh, how often those two go hand in hand! — and I loved to show off in subtle, underhanded ways.  I did my share of Hall Time, but I probably deserved more.  Even with this common ground, though, I don’t feel bad for those kids. I remember what it was like, the sweet thrill of “getting away with” goofing off (no one really gets away with it; teachers just don’t choose to discipline in every single case.)  They’ve had their fun; now I’ll have mine.  And I won’t lie — it is fun being able to elicit that kind of reaction with just a few words and one click of your shoe on the tiled floor of the English hallway.

Somewhere in these last few years, I have actually become a Teacher.

The Story of Stuff, Continued

Tuesday, May 12th, 2009

I mentioned this great film in a previous post, but thought I would elaborate, since the New York Times is on the bandwagon now:

The Story of Stuff is just what it sounds like: it follows our belongings through the five basic steps of extraction, production, distribution, consumption and disposal.  So, for a newspaper, tree, paper plant, warehouse, newsstand, garbage can.  But newspapers are fairly simple, requiring only pulp and pigment.  What about a computer or a couch?  There are many of those being purchased and thrown away every day, too.  This video takes a hard look at some of the things we allow to happen on the earth that is our home.

I hope you’ll all watch it, just like I hoped all my students would watch it — not because I agree with everything Leonard says.  She’s an unabashed activist with views far more radical than my own.  However, I support her anger.  Whenever I pick up trash off my street or break down and order a salad at Chick-Fil-A, I am appalled at the lack of foresight our culture exhibits.  We use it up and spit it out and repeat this process at a dizzying rate.

Here are a couple of facts from the film that I found pretty shattering:

  • One percent of the materials and goods we use and buy are still in use six months later.  Juuuuust one.  For example, 20 tons of mining waste are created to mine the gold in one gold ring.
  • The top-of-the-chain food with the highest percentage of toxic chemicals?  Human breast milk.  This sounds shocking until you read what my cousins recently discovered: because credit card receipts containing BPA are recyclable, it can be found in all sorts of paper products, including toilet tissue.  Toxics in, toxics out.
  • Recycling, while helpful, will never be enough to “fix” the system: for every can of garbage we throw out or recycle, 70 cans of materials were used to make it.
  • Our national economy peaked in the 1950s, about the same time economists began experimenting with the ideas of planned obsolescence (making things break so we’ll buy new ones) and perceived obsolescence (making things seem outdated so we’ll buy new ones.)

So, like I said, watch it.  Then download the annotated script and check her references.  Even if you don’t agree with everything she says (like I said, I don’t) I hope it will get you thinking.  That’s the point.

Can We Play a Game Today?

Monday, May 11th, 2009

I had a student in my first year of teaching who would ask me this without fail, several times a week.  (This was the same student who, on standardized tests, used to “race” other students to finish as quickly as she could, filling in bubbles without even looking at the questions, so her academic standards could be rightly called into question.)  After politely declining, then ignoring her, I finally came up with a great comeback: “Sure, Grace.  Come up with a game that helps me teach the lesson for the day, and the class is all yours.”  The queries stopped shortly thereafter.

Grace’s desire for fun extends to all students, though — including the brightest ones.  If you can think of a way to make it fun, you can guarantee the students will remember more information for longer than if you’d just lectured and given a quiz.

The appeal of games spreads further than the classroom.  Last weekend I threw a baby shower for my goddaughter Juliana, who recently had an adorable little girl.  Juliana is very reserved, especially in large groups (there were about a dozen ladies there), though she sometimes lets me see her more fun-loving side.  I wanted to find a game that was fun (no word searches; no blindfolded diapering) and would let her be the center of attention without putting her on the spot.  Since a few of my cousins and I had played Scattergories at a wedding the week before, the idea was fresh in my mind.  I decided to create categories based on pregnancy and birth: “Items Found in a Diaper Bag,” “Unforeseen Expenses,” and “Nursery Rhymes.”  Then I made another set of categories that had to do with Juliana herself: favorite foods, things she likes to do, places she and her fiance have been together.

I thought it would be fun, but I had no idea how fun.  People loved it.  Scattergories encourages you to manipulate phrases; if the category is “Nursery Rhymes” and the letter is B, you can try to get away with “Bo Peep, Little,” or you can get double points for alliteration, like “Bye Baby Bunting” (that came from my mother, who wins just about ever word-related game I’ve ever seen her play.)  Debates often broke out, but Juliana was the judge, so if we questioned anything she got to decide.  This became especially fun when we got to the rounds about her.  Things she enjoys, E?  Elevator rides, someone guessed.  Juliana wrinkled her nose: “No, I’m afraid of elevators!”

How can I make this into a teaching game?  Maybe review for the final exam?  “Things Lizzie Bennet loves / hates about Mr. Darcy?” “Ways Torvald controls Nora?”  Still working out the kinks, I guess.